Traditional vs. Digital: The Changing Educational Content Scene - Updated

What once seemed like the most economical and practical learning tool—printed textbooks—is fast being replaced by digital solutions that are lower in cost and easier to update. As the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated digital transformation in schools, technology is now progressing in leaps and bounds, and our world is evolving with it.

So, what does this mean for the future of printed textbooks? And what are the ripple effects on students and schools switching to all digital tools?

The Exciting Shift from Print to Digital Textbooks

As the Internet increasingly takes over different facets of life, traditional educational methods were ripe for a shake-up even before the pandemic. Printed textbook information is static, and the books are heavy, costly, and quickly become outdated. Realizing this, textbook manufacturers have moved to producing digital textbooks that are packed with interactive features while being lightweight (or the weight of a student’s mobile device), less expensive, and easily updated with the latest and greatest information.

Learning through a digital medium enables students to:

  • Search for desired information, just like on Google.
  • Instantly access a library of digital textbooks.
  • Access learning aids, like interactive maps and subject-related speeches and documentaries.
  • Interact with homework-help tools, like sites that grade not only for grammar but for sentence structure and repetitive ideas.

At some schools, the switch to digital textbooks was making waves in and out of the classroom, even before the shift to remote and hybrid learning. Due to the lack of physical textbooks, lockers have become so obsolete that students rarely use them or schools remove them entirely. Architects building new schools even exclude them from building plans. As students increasingly carry school items with them at all times, digital textbooks will lighten their load and provide access to all their materials at any time.

Another positive of digital textbooks is undoubtedly their price tag. Since new content can be uploaded at any time, digital textbooks eliminate the cost of replacing print textbooks every few years. Additionally, schools can give students access to open-source educational resources—wells of information, free for anyone to use.

Possibly the most impactful effects of digital textbooks are on learning itself. Print textbooks have immutable information, small margins, and lack engaging characteristics. By contrast, some newly developed digital counterparts, such as the digital textbooks on this list from Hapara, encourage a personalized learning experience.

“Digital textbooks have many benefits for schools and districts since they are easy to distribute and update and don’t require storage. In addition, educators and learners can access them on multiple devices at any time. 

Digital textbooks are also often interactive…. allow[ing] learners to digitally highlight, take notes, bookmark, watch videos and use quick search tools.”

With schools moving to adopt digital textbooks, there are some “pros” and “cons” to consider as they make the switch from print.

Print vs. Digital: Research Shows the Pros and Cons

You might be tempted to think the act of studying a printed text—flipping pages, highlighting and scribbling notes, and folding corners down—doesn’t contribute to greater learning comprehension, but new findings suggest otherwise.

A number of research studies show that readers tend to skim text on screens, leading to distractions and decreased comprehension. In her book, “Words Onscreen: The Fate of Reading in a Digital World,” Naomi S. Baron cites research showing that readers spend a little more than one minute on Web pages, and only 16 percent of people read word-by-word—which is a problem as readers try to consume longer pieces of text on-screen. Reading digitally is faster, but it comes at a cost to overall comprehension.

What’s more, survey responses show 90 percent of students will multi-task while reading on-screen, but just one percent will multi-task while reading hard copy text. A singular focus while reading printed textbooks might contribute to increased learning comprehension.

But before you throw in the towel on digital learning, consider the conclusions other studies have reached. An analysis of several studies on the print vs. digital debate reveals interesting insights:

  • Students overwhelmingly prefer to read on digital mediums.
  • They read significantly faster online than in print.
  • For general questions (like understanding the main idea of the text), the medium does not matter.

Despite varied research, school districts continue to see the positive aspects of adopting digital textbooks over continuing to use print. But before making the transition, there are several additional factors to keep in mind.

Factors to Consider When Adopting Digital Textbooks

School districts that want to make the switch from print to digital textbooks have several potential hurdles to overcome. First, states generally only change textbooks on 7-to-10-year cycles, which means if a print textbook was purchased last year, convincing officials to spend money this year on new digital technology and textbooks might be a challenge.

Second, even though the cost of laptops and tablets has gone down drastically in the past decade, making the case for the extra expense these pose could take some work.

Third, some students may not have Internet access at home. This is a significant problem, as these students can miss out on several hours’ worth of study each night compared to their peers who can log onto the Internet to access textbooks and educational resources. There are tools, however, to remedy this problem, such as Kajeet SmartSpot® devices, filtered WiFi hotspots. As more and more school districts examine the costs and benefits of making the switch from print to digital textbooks, equal access to the Internet is a top-of-mind concern.

If your school or district is exploring the change to digital textbooks, contact us today and we will work together to close the Homework Gap between your students who have Internet access and those who don’t.

Get Your Students Connected

Tag(s): Blog Posts , Education

Other posts you might be interested in

View All Posts